What is the Best Music for Neurofeedback Training?

Abstract

The nucleus accumbens (NAc) is widely known for its role in reward seeking behavior which is heavily reliant on dopamine signaling. Dopamine plays an important role in reward seeking behavior and motivation and its dysregulation is shown to cause symptoms of depression such as apathy, a lack of motivation, and anhedonia, a loss of pleasure. Studying the NAc, specifically the ventral striatum in this case, is critical in understanding the underlying mechanisms of this dysregulation. Music neurofeedback is a biofeedback technique that provides feedback on brain activity through the audio quality of the music, with lower quality sounding more muffled. This study uses this technique to train participants to increase the activity of their ventral striatum in an attempt to upregulate the activity of the reward system.

This paper aims to investigate what the most effective music choices are in terms of genre, key, valence (positive or negative emotions) and energy (pertaining to levels of arousal) to maximize the improvement on neurofeedback training. These musical attributes were identified by the Spotify “Organize Your Music” categorization tool. Participants underwent six EEG music neurofeedback training sessions with individually tailored pleasurable music as the source of feedback. The participants either received real feedback in the neurofeedback group (NF) or sham feedback in the control group. The results of this study showed that neurofeedback performance was negatively correlated with valence whereby songs that led to the greatest performance, measured as increase in ventral striatum activity from baseline, were those low in valence. Participants that had the greatest improvement in their neurofeedback training selected songs that were in a minor key and belonged to the pop genre. Although this study is based on a small sample, it takes the first step towards the overarching goal of using music to manage dysregulation in the reward system.